The neighbours didn’t get angry out of nowhere. Some of that anger was earned, and it was earned by people in my industry.

On our first build, the spreadsheet wanted eight.

Big mid-block lot. Room on paper. We ran the drawings. Then we ran them again. Black line after black line, layout after layout. Eight units. Then seven. Then back to eight.

I’ll be honest. Eight looked good on a spreadsheet.

So we went and stood inside other people’s buildings. Real projects, with real tenants living in them. We looked at where the light came in, and where it didn’t. What you saw out the window. Where the front doors landed and how the whole thing sat on the street.

One version turned the units sideways just to squeeze them onto the lot. We threw that one out almost as fast as it came in. Nobody wants to live sideways.

It didn’t line up. Not at eight. Not at seven.

We built six.

Every redesign cost us time, and it added up to three or four months before we even got moving. Fewer units of rent, forever.

Looking back, it was one of the best decisions we ever made. We built homes people actually want to live in.

Because that’s the only test that matters. We’re going to own these homes for the next 10 to 15 years, probably longer. They have to stand the test of time, not the test of a spreadsheet.

The Gift That Becomes The Problem

I love real estate investors. I am one. I’ve spent 26 years around them.

Investors are a backbone of housing in this country. When the rules open a door, we walk through it. We see opportunity before most people know it’s there. We move capital, take risk, and build homes that wouldn’t exist without us.

That’s the gift.

Here’s the problem. It’s the same gift.

When Edmonton opened up its zoning, a lot of investors heard permission. Some heard an instruction. The bylaw said eight units, so the plan said eight. It allowed 10.5 metres, so the building went 10.5. And with no parking minimum since 2020, the parking went to zero.

Because they could.

The bylaw is a ceiling, not a target.

The rules tell you the most you’re allowed to build. They have never once told you the most you should build. That part was always your job.

When Neighbours Start Signing Covenants

Want to know how far trust has slipped?

In parts of Edmonton, homeowners have been signing restrictive covenants on their own lots so no multiplex can ever be built there. Entire Facebook groups exist to fight infill. Neighbours are posting photos of the narrow gap between their house and the new build next door.

You can roll your eyes at that. Plenty of people in my industry do.

I don’t.

That’s not a zoning problem. That’s a trust problem. And trust doesn’t break on one bad building. It breaks on a pattern.

Beware The Property Promoters

You know the pitch. You’ve probably had it in your inbox.

It usually comes from someone who doesn’t live in the city. Often someone who’s never owned one of these buildings themselves. And it almost never starts with the building.

It starts with the financing.

5% down. 50-year amortization. Look at the leverage. Look at the cash-on-cash. Look at how little you need to get in.

Nobody talks about the design. Nobody talks about the build quality. Nobody talks about the tenant who’s going to live there for the next 10 years.

I’ve said it for a long time: never let the financing tail wag the dog.

Financing matters. It’s a tool, and a great one when the deal underneath is good. But when the financing package IS the deal, you’re not buying a building. You’re buying a pitch.

I wrote about the pricing side of this in Fantasy Island Pricing. Same pattern, different costume. The person selling you the deal usually gets paid at the start, and you hold it for the next ten years. Their risk ends right where yours begins.

And the pattern repeats. Max the units. Max the height. Cut the parking. Run the proforma until it sings. Sell it to someone who’s never stood on that street. Move to the next lot.

The promoter is gone before the first winter. If you remember the Simpsons monorail episode, you already know how that story ends.

Who’s left? The investor who bought the pitch, holding it for the next 10 to 15 years. The tenant who can’t park within a block of home. The neighbour staring at a wall where the sunset used to be.

That’s the difference. I’m not the one selling the pitch. I’m the one who builds it, owns it, and is still standing there in year fifteen. I’m not going anywhere.

Two Places The Spreadsheet Lies

Ceiling height.

Under Edmonton’s new 9.5-metre height cap, you can still squeeze three storeys onto a mid-block lot. On paper. You get there by shaving ceilings until the units feel like a parking garage with drywall.

We go the other way. We over-spec our ceilings. Tall ceilings cost more, and the spreadsheet hates them. But the best tenant walks in, looks up, and breathes. That’s the tenant who stays, pays on time and treats the place like home.

Parking.

Parking is the first line item to go when someone’s chasing one more unit. Pave less, build more, the proforma gets prettier.

Whoever’s selling the deal saves that money once. The tenant pays for it every single day. Circling the block. Hauling groceries from three streets over. Parking in front of the neighbour’s house, and adding one more name to that Facebook group.

That first build, the one the spreadsheet wanted eight on? Six units. Parking for eight. No one’s circling the block.

Decide based on the living experience, not the spreadsheet.

The Seesaw

Now let me be honest, because I’m not going to pretend this is easy.

The numbers still have to work. Land costs what it costs. Construction costs what it costs. Financing costs what it costs. Every unit you don’t build is revenue you don’t collect, and every extra stall is ground you don’t build on.

It’s a seesaw. Always has been.

That first build proved it. Fewer units, months of delay, real money on the table.

I’m not asking you to ignore the math. I’m asking you to notice which side you lean toward when it’s close. We lean toward the person who lives there. Every time. Sometimes that costs us on paper. It has never cost us a good tenant.

Walk It As The Tenant

Take your current deal, or the next one you’re looking at, and walk it as the tenant. Not the owner. Not the lender. The person carrying groceries.

  1. Where do I park? Not in theory. Tonight, at 6pm, in February.
  2. Where do the bins go? Garbage, recycling, compost, times however many units.
  3. Where does my stuff go? Bike, stroller, snow tires, hockey bag.
  4. What do I see out the bedroom window?
  5. Would I renew my lease here?

Then do what we did. Go stand inside a building like the one you’re about to build, with people living in it. One afternoon will tell you more than a hundred rows of a spreadsheet.

If you can’t answer all five without wincing, you’re not done underwriting.

And if your project only works at the absolute maximum, ask yourself one question. Would I live in the unit my spreadsheet just approved?

If the answer is no, it’s not too late. Redesign. Drop a unit. Add a stall. Raise a ceiling. I believe you can build something you’d be proud to own for 15 years. Most of you already want to. The spreadsheet just got loud.

Here’s the good news. There’s a whole group of investors who read the province’s announcement and barely blinked. They aren’t building to sell and move on. They’re building to own, for the long haul. And they’d been doing it right all along.

That’s where we go next.

In your corner,


Russell Westcott
#Inspire #Encourage #Love

The Edmonton Infill Deep Dive

Part 1: The Problem Every Other City Wants
Part 2: Right Answer, Wrong Room
Part 3: Just Because You Can (you are here)
Part 4: Business as Usual

 

Just Because You Can

by Oct 15, 2026Development, Real Estate0 comments

Book Your FREE Consultation Today!

Private One-on-One Personal Consultations